Fruitcake
EP by Sabrina Carpenter
Released	November 17, 2023 (2023-11-17)
Studio	Playpen Studios, Perch Studios (Calabasas), The Nest (Nashville)
Genre	Christmas pop
Length	15:46
Label	Island
Producer	Julian Bunetta John Ryan
Sabrina Carpenter chronology
Emails I Can't Send (2022) Fruitcake (2023) Short n' Sweet (2024)
Singles from Fruitcake
"A Nonsense Christmas" Released: December 7, 2022 "Santa Doesn't Know You Like I Do" Released: November 17, 2023

Fruitcake is the second extended play (EP) and first Christmas themed record by American singer Sabrina Carpenter. It was released by Island Records on November 17, 2023. It was produced by Julian Bunetta and John Ryan.

Prior to signing with Island Records in 2021, Carpenter released various Christmas songs including "Christmas the Whole Year Round" which reached number 17 on the US Holiday Digital Song Sales chart.^[1][2] In December 2022, following the success of her fifth studio album Emails I Can't Send, Carpenter released a Christmas remix of her single "Nonsense", titled "A Nonsense Christmas".^[3]

A year later, on November 8, 2023, Carpenter announced that she would be releasing her first Christmas-themed EP,^[4] and revealed its track list through a post on her social media accounts.^[5][6] The EP was released on November 17, 2023.^[7][8] On her website, the announcement followed the same aesthetic of her album Emails I Can't Send (2022), being presented in a designed email-style.^[8]

The EP begins with "A Nonsense Christmas", a holiday remix of her viral single "Nonsense".^[9][10] Throughout the song, Carpenter sings puns about Charles Dickens, Christmas Tree trimmings, and was described as "goofy and unserious".^[10] Carpenter also changed the lyrics to the song to match the Christmas-theme with lyrics "Sounds like bleh-blah-blee" changed to "Sounds like ho ho ho".^{[11] [12]} Carpenter also recorded a new outro for the song.^[10] "Buy Me Presents" follows with similar Christmas-themed wordplay and was described as a "bright and bouncing tongue in cheek love song".^[10][13] The song features a saxophone-solo against a "smooth atmospheric production" and is reminiscent of a Hallmark movie soundtrack.^[13][14]

"Santa Doesn't Know You Like I Do" is a ballad and shifts the mood of the EP.^[13] Described as a sad love song,^[15] and featured a spoken word bridge which was described as a callback to Carpenter's 2022 single "Skinny Dipping".^[13] The production of the song was called a "juxtaposition between the snare kicks and gentle production" which works towards creating a sombre atmosphere.^[13] This is followed by "Cindy Lou Who" which is named after the How the Grinch Stole Christmas character of the same name.^[10] The song tells the story of a heartbreak leading to the singer questioning her feelings about her ex-lover's new girlfriend.^[10][9]

Carpenter follows this with a pop-infused song "Is It New Years Yet?" where she wants to "skip past Christmas because everyone has a partner to spend" it with.^[15] The song was compared to "Dance the Night",^[15] and sings that "Fruitcake just makes [her] sick".^[13] The EP closes with a cover of Irving Berlin's "White Christmas" titled "White Xmas".^[13][8] Carpenter's vocals were called a highlight of the song, being described as an outro rather than a full-song.^[13] The song also interpolates "Jingle Bells".^[13]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[16]

Upon release, the EP was well received by critics. Alex Hopper of American Songwriter complimented Carpenter for not relying exclusively on traditional Christmas songs and for writing original material.^[17] Amy Britton of The Indiependent wrote that the record is "a sugary sweet musical feast" and that, although it was full of the "usual Christmas song stereotypes", it kept the artist's essence.^[18]

Sabrina Carpenter's holiday music has earned significant recognition from various publications. Her song "A Nonsense Christmas" was ranked by Billboard as the 14th best song of the 21st century.^[19] Additionally, Cosmopolitan magazine ranked it 77th on their list of top Christmas songs.^[20] Carpenter's song, "Santa Doesn't Know You Like I Do," was ranked by Parade magazine as the 203rd best Christmas song of all time.^[21]

Note

• ^{^[v]} signifies a vocal producer

Musicians

• Sabrina Carpenter – lead vocals
• Julian Bunetta – programming (tracks 1, 3), background vocals (1); bass, drums, keyboards, percussion (3)
• Steph Jones – background vocals (track 1)
• John Ryan – bass, guitar, keyboards, programming (tracks 2, 4–6); synthesizer (2, 4, 5), drums (2, 5, 6), percussion (5), organ (6)
• Leon Silva – saxophone (track 2)
• Rob Moose – viola, violin (tracks 4, 6)

Technical

• Nathan Dantzler – mastering
• Julian Bunetta – mixing, engineering (track 1)
• Rob Kinelski – mixing (tracks 2–6)
• Jeff Gunnell – engineering (tracks 2–5)
• Rob Moose – string arrangement (tracks 4, 6)
• Eli Heisler – mixing assistance (tracks 2–6)