From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
(Learn how and when to remove this message)
|
1939 United States Supreme Court case
Buck v. Gallagher | |
---|---|
Argued January 10, 1939 Decided April 17, 1939 | |
Full case name | Buck v. Gallagher |
Citations | 307 U.S. 95 (more) 59 S. Ct. 740; 83 L. Ed. 1128 |
Holding | |
1) ASCAP members have a common and undivided interest in the right to license in association through the Society free of the state statute. 2) The lower court should have allowed ASCAP members the opportunity to price the cost of complying with the statute and the value of the copyrights affected by it. | |
Court membership | |
| |
Case opinions | |
Majority | Reed |
Dissent | Black |
Buck v. Gallagher, 307 U.S. 95 (1939), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court had two main holdings. First, American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers (ASCAP) members have a common and undivided interest in the right to license in association through the Society free of the state statute. Second, the lower court should have allowed ASCAP members the opportunity to price the cost of complying with the statute and the value of the copyrights affected by it.[1]
References
[edit]External links
[edit]- Text of Buck v. Gallagher, 307 U.S. 95 (1939) is available from: Cornell CourtListener Findlaw Google Scholar Justia Library of Congress
This article related to the Supreme Court of the United States is a stub. You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. |
Hidden categories:
- Use mdy dates from September 2023
- Wikipedia articles needing context from October 2019
- All Wikipedia articles needing context
- All pages needing cleanup
- Articles lacking reliable references from December 2019
- All articles lacking reliable references
- Articles with multiple maintenance issues
- Articles with short description
- Short description matches Wikidata
- All stub articles
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url
url